Best Property Management Companies in Salt Lake City
2026 Owner's Comparison Guide
Choosing a property management company can have a significant impact on the performance of a rental property.
The right manager should do more than collect rent. Property owners should consider tenant screening, leasing performance, maintenance oversight, communication, inspections, financial reporting, guarantees, local experience—and the total cost of management.
Salt Lake City and the Wasatch Front have a number of established property management companies, each with a somewhat different approach.
To help Utah rental owners compare their options, we reviewed nine companies that regularly appear in searches for property management services in the Salt Lake City and Wasatch Front markets:
- TierOne Real Estate
- Wolfnest Property Management
- Keyrenter Salt Lake
- Rize Property Management
- Reeder Asset Management
- HomeRiver Group Utah
- Kodiak Property Management
- ProRenter Property Management
- Nestwell Property Management
This guide isn't intended to declare that one company is right for every landlord. Instead, it compares publicly available pricing, services, guarantees and management models so owners can decide which approach best fits their property and investment goals.
Pricing and programs can change. Information below was reviewed in September 2026. Property owners should confirm current pricing and terms directly with each company before making a decision.
Get started with your FREE PROPERTY CONSULTATION by completing the form .
Schedule Your Free Consultation
Quick Pricing Comparison
Services Offered |
Published Monthly Management Fee |
Published Leasing / Tenant Placement Fee |
Notable Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| TierOne Real Estate | 7.5% single-family; 10.5% condo; 6.5% 2–4 units |
$250 with full-service management | 21-Day Rental, Management Fee, 12-Month Lease, Happiness and Eviction Protection guarantees |
| Wolfnest | Tiered pricing; verify current plan |
Varies by plan | 28-day leasing guarantee and published performance statistics |
| Keyrenter Salt Lake | 9% | 35% of one month's rent |
21-point screening and multiple service guarantees |
| Rize Property Management | 10% single-family; 8% multifamily |
$0 with full-service management | Full-service and higher-level asset-management options |
| Reeder Asset Management | 5%, 7% or 10% depending on plan |
75%, 50% or 0% depending on plan |
Three pricing structures plus extensive guarantees |
| HomeRiver Group Utah | 10%; 8% for 4+ units |
$0 | No leasing fee or maintenance markup |
| Kodiak Property Management | $75 + 3.9%; $75 + 5.9%; or $85 + 7.9% |
$999, $599 or $299 depending on plan |
Multiple service levels and 30-day rental guarantee |
| ProRenter | 8%–10% | See current fee schedule | Performance-based model and several owner guarantees |
| Nestwell | 8.9% Full Service; 11.9% Premium |
39% or 49% of one month's rent |
Extensive protection programs and three annual property evaluations on Full Service |
Pricing alone doesn't tell the whole story. A lower management percentage can be offset by leasing fees, renewal charges, maintenance coordination fees, inspection charges or other expenses. Conversely, a higher monthly fee may include services another company charges separately.
Owners should compare the total expected annual cost, not simply the advertised management percentage.
Salt Lake City Property Management Companies Compared
TierOne Real Estate
TierOne Real Estate is a locally focused Utah real estate brokerage and property management company managing several hundred rental units. Its services include rental analysis, marketing, tenant screening, leasing, rent collection, maintenance coordination, inspections, financial reporting and eviction assistance.
Published pricing
For full-service management, TierOne currently publishes:
- Single-family home / one unit: 7.5% of monthly rent
- Condo: 10.5%
- 2–4 units: 6.5%
- 5+ units: Custom
- Tenant placement with full-service management: $250
- Lease renewal: $250
- Initial setup: $0
- Monthly technology fee: $0
- In-house maintenance markup: 0%
Minimums and certain additional charges may apply.
Guarantees
TierOne publishes five primary owner guarantees:
- 21-Day Rental Guarantee: If a qualifying property isn't rented within 21 days, the owner receives two months of management fees free.
- Management Fee Guarantee: TierOne doesn't collect its management fee until the tenant pays rent, subject to stated exceptions.
- 12-Month Lease Guarantee: If a TierOne-placed tenant leaves before completing the guaranteed lease period, TierOne will find a replacement without another leasing fee, subject to stated exclusions.
- Happiness Guarantee: Owners who aren't satisfied can cancel management without a cancellation penalty.
- Eviction Package Guarantee: Owners enrolled in the protection program can receive up to $1,000 toward qualifying eviction filing costs.
Potential fit
TierOne may appeal particularly to owners looking for a locally operated company, transparent published pricing, a relatively low tenant-placement charge under full-service management, in-house maintenance capabilities and multiple performance guarantees.
Wolfnest Property Management
Wolfnest is a well-established Salt Lake City property management company with a strong emphasis on measurable performance and owner guarantees.
One thing Wolfnest does particularly well is publish operating statistics rather than relying exclusively on general marketing claims.
Wolfnest reports more than 16,000 rental applications processed and an eviction rate below 1%.
Guarantees & Protections
- 28-Day Leasing Guarantee
- 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
- Up to $2,000 Pet Damage Guarantee
- A published 0.5% Eviction Rate
Its satisfaction guarantee allows owners to cancel with 30 days' notice if they aren't satisfied, subject to the management agreement.
Potential fit
Wolfnest may be attractive to owners who place substantial value on published performance metrics, leasing guarantees and pet-damage protection.
Keyrenter Salt Lake
Keyrenter Salt Lake uses a straightforward full-service pricing structure and emphasizes screening, technology and operational systems.
Published pricing
Keyrenter currently publishes:
- Monthly management: 9% of rent
- Leasing fee: 35% of one month's rent
- Discounts available for multiple properties
Tenant screening
Keyrenter advertises a 21-point tenant-screening process, which is one of the more explicitly defined screening programs among the companies compared here.
Potential fit
Keyrenter may be worth considering for owners who want a standardized management system, relatively straightforward pricing and an extensive documented screening process.
Rize Property Management
Rize Property Management serves both single-family and multifamily investors and offers a separate premium asset-management service for owners seeking more detailed portfolio-level reporting and oversight.
Published pricing
For single-family properties, Rize currently publishes:
- Full-Service Management: 10% of monthly rent
- Tenant placement: Included
For multifamily properties, Rize publishes:
- Full-Service Management: 8% of monthly rent
- Tenant placement: Included
Rize also offers a Premium Asset Management program with additional portfolio reporting, budgeting, forecasting, financial management and tenant-retention services.
Potential fit
Rize may be particularly relevant to investors with multifamily properties or larger portfolios who want management to extend beyond day-to-day leasing and maintenance into asset-level financial and operational reporting.
Reeder Asset Management
Reeder Asset Management takes a somewhat different approach by offering three service packages that change the balance between monthly management fees and transaction-based charges.
Published pricing
goESSENTIAL
- Management: 5%
- New tenant placement: 75% of one month's rent
- Renewal: 20% of one month's rent
- Vendor coordination: 10%
goBLEND
- Management: 7%
- New tenant placement: 50% of one month's rent
- Renewal: 10% of one month's rent
- Vendor coordination: 5%
goCOMPLETE
- Management: 10%
- New tenant placement: 0% of one month's rent
- Renewal: 0% of one month's rent
- Vendor coordination: 0%
This is an important example of why owners shouldn't compare property managers solely by monthly management percentage.
Guarantees
Reeder advertises several protections, including:
- Love Us or Leave Us Guarantee
- Pay for Performance Guarantee
- 21-Day Leasing Guarantee
- Tenant Guarantee
- Eviction protection up to stated limits
- Pet-damage protection up to stated limits
Potential fit
Reeder's tiered model may be useful for owners who want to choose how much of their management expense is fixed versus tied to leasing, renewals and maintenance activity.
HomeRiver Group Utah
HomeRiver Group differs from several companies on this list because it is part of a much larger property management organization rather than a small local management company.
Its Utah operation nevertheless publishes unusually simple pricing.
Published pricing
HomeRiver currently advertises:
- Full-service management: 10%
- 4+ units: 8%
- Leasing fee: $0
- Setup fee: $0
- Maintenance markup: $0
- Annual contract requirement: None
Lease renewal is listed at 8%–10% of the first month's rent.
Optional eviction protection and property inspections are available for additional charges.
Potential fit
HomeRiver may appeal to owners who prefer a larger organization, want a no-leasing-fee structure and are comfortable with a 10% monthly management rate for smaller portfolios.
Kodiak Property Management
Kodiak Property Management offers three pricing levels, making its fee structure somewhat different from traditional percentage-only management.
Published pricing
Basic
- $75 + 3.9% of monthly rent
- Tenant placement: $999
- Inspection: $99
- Renewal: $199
Standard
- $75 + 5.9% of monthly rent
- Tenant placement: $599
- Inspection: $59
- Renewal: $99
Premium
- $85 + 7.9% of monthly rent
- Tenant placement: $299
- Inspection: $59
- Renewal: No fee
Services and protections increase with the package selected.
Kodiak also advertises a 30-Day Rental Guarantee, Satisfaction Guarantee, Tenant Retention Guarantee and available eviction protection.
Potential fit
Kodiak's model may work well for owners who want to select among several levels of management service rather than buying a single standardized package.
Because Kodiak combines a base monthly charge with a percentage, owners should calculate the actual effective percentage using their property's expected rent when comparing it with other companies.
ProRenter Property Management
ProRenter operates across Davis, Weber and Salt Lake Counties and emphasizes a performance-based management model.
Published pricing
Its published fee schedule lists:
- Monthly management: 8%–10% of gross rent collected
ProRenter states that it doesn't charge management or leasing fees until a qualified tenant has been placed and rent begins.
Its management services include rent collection, tenant relations, lease enforcement, owner and tenant portals, move-in/move-out inspections, emergency maintenance access, financial reporting and deposit disposition.
Guarantees
ProRenter advertises:
- Results Guarantee: No management or leasing fees until a qualified tenant is placed and rent begins.
- Satisfaction Guarantee: Owners can cancel with 30 days' notice without a long-term commitment.
- Leasing Guarantee: If a qualifying tenant doesn't complete at least nine months of the initial 12-month lease, ProRenter will replace the tenant without an additional leasing charge.
- Eviction Protection Guarantee: Up to $1,000 toward qualifying attorney costs involving a tenant ProRenter screened and placed.
Potential fit
ProRenter may be especially relevant for owners in Davis and Weber Counties who want a management company with substantial operations north of Salt Lake City while still serving the broader Wasatch Front.
Nestwell Property Management
Nestwell offers both Full Service and Premium management packages and has one of the more extensive published service menus among the companies compared.
Published pricing
Full Service
- Monthly management: 8.9%
- Minimum: $150/month
- New tenant placement: 39% of one month's rent
- Lease renewal: $150
- Setup: $45
- Three annual property evaluations: $50 per report
Premium Service
- Monthly management: 11.9%
- Minimum: $200/month
- New tenant placement: 49% of one month's rent
Nestwell also advertises a variety of owner protections and optional services, including an Eviction Shield program, rent-loss protection and a $100,000 Asset Protection Program.
Experience
Nestwell states that its team has more than 40 years of local real estate/property-management experience.
Potential fit
Nestwell may appeal to owners who want a highly structured management package with frequent property evaluations and multiple optional risk-protection services.
How Much Does Property Management Actually Cost?
The comparison illustrates why asking only, "What's your management percentage?" can lead owners to the wrong conclusion.
Consider a hypothetical rental collecting $2,500 per month.
A manager charging 7.5% collects $187.50 per month in base management fees.
A manager charging 10% collects $250.
That's a difference of $750 per year.
But if the 7.5% manager charges substantially more for leasing, renewals, inspections or maintenance coordination, the apparent savings could disappear.
The opposite can also occur: a company with a higher monthly percentage may include tenant placement and other services that another manager bills separately.
"What should I expect to pay you during a normal three-year ownership period?"
Ask each company to estimate:
- Monthly management fees
- Initial tenant-placement or leasing fees
- Lease-renewal fees
- Inspection charges
- Maintenance markups or coordination charges
- Setup or onboarding fees
- Technology or administrative fees
- Eviction-protection costs
- Cancellation charges
- Any other mandatory owner fees
Then compare the estimated total cost of management.
Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Salt Lake City Property Manager
Pricing should only be part of the decision. An owner interviewing property managers should also ask:
-
How many properties do you currently manage?
Size isn't automatically better, but it helps reveal whether the company has enough infrastructure to handle leasing, accounting, inspections, maintenance and after-hours emergencies. -
Who will actually manage my property?
Ask whether you'll have a dedicated property manager, a team-based system or a centralized service model -
How do you screen tenants?
Don't settle for "we run a background check." Ask about credit, income verification, employment, rental history, criminal screening, eviction history and pet or animal screening. -
What happens when my property is vacant?
Ask how the property is priced, photographed, advertised and shown—and how often pricing is reevaluated if applications aren't coming in. -
Do you profit from maintenance?
There's nothing inherently wrong with a company earning money for coordinating maintenance, but owners should understand whether the manager adds a markup, charges a coordination fee, uses an affiliated maintenance company or passes vendor invoices through at cost. -
How often will someone physically inspect my property?
A management company can collect rent perfectly for years while an unnoticed property problem becomes increasingly expensive. -
What happens if I'm unhappy?
Read the termination clause before signing. Some companies advertise cancellation guarantees or month-to-month agreements; others may have different notice or termination requirements. -
What guarantees are actually in writing?
A guarantee on a website sounds reassuring, but owners should review the conditions and exclusions. -
How quickly do you respond?
Ask who handles owner calls, tenant emergencies and maintenance requests—and what happens outside normal business hours. -
Can you show me the complete fee schedule?
Don't rely on the headline management percentage. Request every potential owner charge in writing.
Local Company vs. National Property Manager
Salt Lake owners also face a broader decision: whether to use a locally operated company or a larger regional or national management organization.
Neither model is automatically better.
A larger organization may offer substantial technology, standardized procedures, centralized staffing and greater geographic reach.
A local company may provide greater familiarity with individual Utah submarkets, more direct access to decision-makers and more flexibility when unusual situations arise.
Owners who expect to acquire properties in multiple states may place more value on national reach.
An owner whose portfolio is concentrated along the Wasatch Front may put more weight on Utah-specific experience and local relationships.
The important question isn't which model is universally better.
It's which model fits your portfolio.
Which Salt Lake City Property Manager Is Best?
There isn't one property management company that's best for every Utah rental owner.
Based on publicly available programs and pricing:
- Owners focused heavily on guarantees may want to compare TierOne, Reeder, Wolfnest, Kodiak, and ProRenter closely.
- Owners looking primarily at low tenant-placement costs should compare TierOne with companies such as HomeRiver and Rize that incorporate tenant placement differently into their full-service pricing.
- Owners wanting several service levels may find the package structures from Reeder, Kodiak, and Nestwell useful.
- Multifamily investors should look carefully at companies, like TierOne, with dedicated multifamily or asset-management programs.
- Owners who prefer a large organizational platform may find HomeRiver appealing.
- Owners looking for a locally focused full-service manager with transparent pricing and multiple performance guarantees may find TierOne a strong candidate.
The final decision should be based on more than the lowest advertised fee.
The best property manager is the company that can consistently protect the property, place qualified residents, control vacancy and maintenance costs, communicate effectively, maintain accurate financial records and help the owner achieve the best long-term return.
Comparing TierOne Real Estate
We recognize an obvious limitation of this comparison
TierOne Real Estate published it.
That's why we've tried to distinguish publicly verifiable facts from opinions and include companies we believe Utah rental owners may legitimately consider.
We encourage owners to interview multiple property managers, review their management agreements and fee schedules, read both owner and tenant reviews, and ask difficult questions before deciding.
But don't choose us because we wrote a comparison article.
Compare us.
Ask us for our complete pricing. Read our guarantees. Review our screening process. Compare our agreement against the other companies you're considering.
If another property manager is a better fit for your investment, you should hire them.
If TierOne provides the combination of cost, protection, experience and service you're looking for, we'd welcome the opportunity to manage your property.
- 7.5% published single-family management rate
- $250 tenant-placement fee with full-service management
- No initial setup fee
- No monthly technology fee
- No markup when using TierOne's in-house handyman service
- 21-Day Rental Guarantee
- Management Fee Guarantee
- 12-Month Lease Guarantee
- Happiness Guarantee
- Available Eviction Package Guarantee
- Local Utah property-management and real-estate experience
- Full-service leasing, management, accounting, maintenance and brokerage capabilities
- 7.5% published single-family management rate
- $250 tenant-placement fee with full-service management
- No initial setup fee
- No monthly technology fee
- No markup when using TierOne's in-house handyman service
- 21-Day Rental Guarantee
- Management Fee Guarantee
- 12-Month Lease Guarantee
- Happiness Guarantee
- Available Eviction Package Guarantee
- Local Utah property-management and real-estate experience
- Full-service leasing, management, accounting, maintenance and brokerage capabilities
Get a Free Rental Analysis
Not sure what your Salt Lake or Wasatch Front rental should rent for—or whether professional management makes financial sense?
TierOne Real Estate can prepare a rental analysis and walk you through the expected management costs before you make a decision.
No pressure. Just the numbers you need to make an informed choice.
Last reviewed: September 2026. Pricing, guarantees and services described in this guide are based on publicly available information from each company's website and may change. Certain guarantees have eligibility requirements, exclusions and other conditions. Verify current pricing and contract terms directly with each property management company before making a decision.